54 pages • 1 hour read
S. J. WatsonA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of domestic violence.
Christine wakes up and is aware that she is a mother. She remembers Adam’s name and feels love for her husband. However, when she sees Ben lying next to her, she is confused, expecting to see a man named Ed. As she recalls the name, Christine thinks that Ed could be the man who attacked her.
That night, Christine tells Ben that she vaguely remembers the incident that caused her amnesia. She pleads with him to tell her the truth. Ben tells her she is imagining things and insists she was hit by a car. Christine secretly calls Dr. Nash and says she remembers being attacked. Dr. Nash is with his girlfriend and says he cannot talk. He advises Christine to write the memory down, and he will see her the next day.
Dr. Nash takes Christine to a café. He explains that he did not know what Ben had told her about the “accident” until he read Christine’s journal. Dr. Nash reveals that Christine was staying in a hotel in Brighton on the night she lost her memory. She was found wandering the streets in a state of confusion with severe head injuries. No one in the hotel saw her attacker.
Dr. Nash explains that Ben did not know what Christine was doing in Brighton and had reported her as missing. Following emergency surgery, Christine was in a coma and woke with amnesia. Doctors assumed the memory loss was caused by her head injury combined with possible strangulation or drowning. Christine was in the hospital for months and was then transferred to a psychiatric ward, where she stayed for seven years. Suffering from paranoia, she attempted to escape and was occasionally violent. Dr. Nash suggests they could visit the Brighton hotel to see if it prompts any memories, but Christine refuses.
Christine realizes that she must have been having an affair and thinks about how the revelation must have affected Ben. It occurs to her that this is why he lied about the cause of her memory loss. Dr. Nash suggests they should visit the psychiatric ward, admitting that he has already prearranged it.
At the psychiatric ward, Dr. Nash tells Christine how Ben successfully campaigned to transfer her to a center specializing in brain injuries. After leaving the psychiatric ward, Christine lived at the center for about 10 years until she was discharged. Christine remembers receiving a hospital visit from Adam as a young boy. She greeted him joyfully but then became confused and ordered him to leave.
Dr. Nash introduces Dr. Hilary Wilson, and Christine vaguely remembers being under her care. Dr. Wilson says Ben, Adam, and Christine’s friend Claire visited most days. In a file, Dr. Wilson has copies of pages from a diary Christine kept in the hospital. The entries, written within minutes of each other, are confused and contradictory. Christine is shocked to learn that her memory sometimes lasted only seconds. She begins to panic, desperate to leave. Dr. Wilson knocks some papers to the floor, and Christine sees a photograph of her face distorted and swollen from cuts and bruises. Horrified, she screams until the two doctors restrain her. Christine breaks free and runs through the ward, realizing she has done this before.
On the drive home, Christine fears for her sanity. When she starts crying, Dr. Nash stops the car. As he puts his arms around Christine, trying to comfort her, another memory is triggered. Christine remembers being forcibly held by a man in the hotel room. There is a three-mirrored dressing table in the room and a picture of a bird. Struggling, she falls to the floor, and the man drags her by the hair. She tries to see his face, but it is a blank. The man hits Christine and drags her to a bathroom with black and white floor tiles. Christine feels herself being throttled and pushed down into the bathwater.
Christine’s memory is interrupted by Dr. Nash shouting her name. She is running across the park, and he is chasing her. Christine stops, telling Dr. Nash that she believes her memory would return if she could remember the identity of her attacker. Christine reveals that, a few days earlier, she thought of the name Ed when she woke up. She suggests that Ed could be the man she had an affair with. Dr. Nash gently informs Christine that his first name is Ed, and he has told her this before. He suggests she is “confabulating.” Embarrassed, Christine realizes that she was fantasizing about waking up with her doctor. Dr. Nash suggests they visit Waring House, the brain injury unit Christine was transferred to, the next time they meet.
Chapter 10 introduces further intrigue when Dr. Nash confirms that a violent attack caused Christine’s injuries. Readers are now presented with the new mystery of who attacked Christine. At the hospital, the photographs of Christine’s facial injuries shockingly convey how brutal the attack was. Although painful, this knowledge gives Christine a more pressing reason for recovering her memory. She wants to remember who attacked her.
Armed with this new information, Christine realizes that Ben was gaslighting her when he insisted that her disturbing flashbacks were “[j]ust [her] mind playing tricks” (182). From this point in the novel, Christine begins to “test” Ben by seeing if he lies about facts she is sure of. Her actions signal her increasing refusal to accept his narrative at face value.
During Christine’s visit to the psychiatric ward, she is shocked by the evidence of her unstable mental state after the attack. Dr. Wilson introduces the recurring theme of confabulation. The doctor explains that amnesiac patients often “feel compelled to invent details […] to fill gaps in the memory” (202). This information, combined with the evidence of her former paranoia, causes Christine to question whether she may be inventing the entries in her journal. Christine’s doubt about her version of events is exacerbated when she tells Dr. Nash that her attacker may be named Ed. When Dr. Nash reveals his first name is Ed, Christine realizes that she was confusing fantasy with reality.